مطالعات بازآفرینی شهری

مطالعات بازآفرینی شهری

توانمندسازی اقتصادی و تاب‌آوری معیشتی در محلات هدف بازآفرینی شهر مشهد(نمونه موردی: محلات معقول و امیرآباد)

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده
دانشگاه تهران، تهران، ایران
10.22034/jurs.2025.521991.1003
چکیده
بازآفرینی پایدار شهری به عنوان یکی از رویکردهای مداخله در بافت‌های فرسوده و ناکارامد شهری است که می‌تواند با رعایت اصول توسعه پایدار، پس از اجرا در ارتقاء ابعاد مختلف کالبدی، اجتماعی، اقتصادی و فرهنگی شهرها نقش موثری داشته باشد. حاشیۀ شهر مشهد به عنوان یک بافت حاشیه ای و ناکارآمد مجموعه ای از مراکز جمعیتی است که طی سال‌ها پیرامون کلان شهر مشهد گسترش یافته و معضلات و مسائل گوناگونی را برای این شهر پدید آورده است. بر این اساس پژوهش حاضر با هدف تقویت نقش و مشارکت فعال ساکنان در فرآیندهای تصمیم‌سازی، برنامه‌ریزی و اجرای پروژه‌های اقتصادی محله‌محور به عنوان یکی از مهم ترین محلات حاشیه نشین منطقه شش مشهد، با استفاده از تکنیک تماتیک، و دلفی و بر پایه مطالعه اسـنادی و میـدانی بـه ویـژه مشاهده‌ها و کشفیات عینی محققین و مصاحبه عمیق نیمه ساختاریافته با 50 نفر از ساکنین، معتمدین و مطلعین تا اشباع نظری انجام شده است. نتایج تحقیق استخراج 10 کد محوری و 5 کدگزینشی را نشان داد. با توجه به نتایج حاصله، مهم ترین مسأله و چالش این محلات نبود شغل مناسب و درخور ساکنین و عدم بهره گیری واحدهای صنعتی و کارگاهی موجود در امیرآباد غربی از نیروی کار بومی محلات، نیروی کار ارزان قیمت افغان و ...  است که به منظور کاهش اثرات آن و توانمندسازی اقتصادی و کمک به ارتقاء تاب آوری معیشتی خانوارهای این بافت پیشنهاد تعریف پروژه‌های محرک توسعه اقتصادی چون تأسیس شرکت تعاونی چند منظوری محلی، روز بازار(عصربازار) و برگزاری دوره‌های مهارت محور گردید.
کلیدواژه‌ها

عنوان مقاله English

Economic empowerment and livelihood resilience in target neighborhoods for Mashhad city regeneration (Case study: maghol and Amirabad neighborhoods)

نویسنده English

mohammad hadi darroodi
university of Tehran, tehran, iran
چکیده English

Sustainable urban regeneration is one of the approaches to intervention in worn-out and inefficient urban contexts, which can play an effective role in promoting various physical, social, economic and cultural dimensions of cities by observing the principles of sustainable development. The outskirts of Mashhad, as a marginal and inefficient context, is a set of population centers that have expanded around the metropolis of Mashhad over the years and have created various problems and issues for this city. Accordingly, the present study aimed to strengthen the role and active participation of residents in the decision-making, planning and implementation processes of neighborhood-based economic projects as one of the most important marginal neighborhoods in the sixth district of Mashhad, using thematic and Delphi techniques and based on documentary and field studies, especially the objective observations and discoveries of researchers, and semi-structured in-depth interviews with 50 residents, confidants and informants until theoretical saturation. The results of the study showed the extraction of 10 axial codes and 5 selective codes. According to the results, the most important issue and challenge of these neighborhoods is the lack of suitable and suitable jobs for residents and the lack of utilization of the local labor force, cheap Afghan labor force, etc. by industrial and workshop units in West Amirabad. In order to reduce its effects, empower the economy, and help improve the livelihood resilience of households in this context, it was proposed to define projects that stimulate economic development, such as establishing a local multi-purpose cooperative, market day (Asrbazaar), and holding skill-based courses.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Sustainable creation
economic empowerment
inefficient fabric
Mashhad city

1- Introduction

Slums in the metropolis of Mashhad have long been a primary concern for urban and national management, and their organization has consistently been identified as the Achilles' heel of urban management. Due to the unplanned development of the city, these neighborhoods have developed an organic, worn-out, and very dense texture that conflicts with their neighboring areas in terms of physical, social, economic, and other characteristics. Despite the high population in these neighborhoods, unfortunately, there has been excessive and unplanned development and expansion, which has led to an unfavorable situation compared to other neighborhoods in the Mashhad metropolis, which has led to the departure of the original residents and the settlement of undocumented immigrants (chalou), non-Iranian nationals, etc. One of the important measures that should be taken as a first step to implement sustainable regeneration as efficiently as possible is to identify the network of problems in the marginalized neighborhoods. As mentioned earlier, one of the reasons for the decline of the city's texture in terms of function and structure is the lack of fit and harmony with the needs and desires of residents, which has increased the process of deterioration. One of the new policies in urban development, particularly in the regeneration of inefficient and disorderly areas, is the implementation of development-stimulating projects aimed at accelerating and facilitating the transformation process in these areas by utilizing local capacities. Meanwhile, urban regeneration and development projects serve as generators to restore prosperity and development to targeted areas, launching a cycle of vibrant and dynamic activity in these areas. Additionally, in dysfunctional urban contexts, where residents may face challenges such as unemployment, poverty, declining public service quality, and inadequate infrastructure, livelihood resilience can serve as a vital tool for the social and economic reconstruction and rehabilitation of neighborhoods. Improving livelihood resilience enables these communities to better respond to and recover from economic, social, and even natural shocks (such as natural disasters or economic crises).

2. Materials and Methods

Based on its purpose, the present research is classified as applied research, and in terms of research methodology, it employs a descriptive-analytical approach. The required information was collected through documentary and field methods, especially through the researchers' objective observations and discoveries, as well as interviews and the organization of audio and video documents. To analyze the interview results, the Delphi method, thematic analysis, and the Steeple technique were employed. The Shahid Maghul and Amirabad neighborhoods, which serve as the study area, are located in the western and southwestern parts of Mashhad's six districts, specifically in the Shahid Rajaee town area. The areas of the Shahid Maghul and Amirabad neighborhoods are 76.3 hectares and 95.2 hectares, respectively, totaling 171 hectares. They have allocated about 9 percent of the area of Mashhad's six districts.

3. Results and Discussion

Considering the main goal of the present study, strengthening the role and active participation of residents in the decision-making processes, planning, and implementation of neighborhood-based economic projects, in this section, a general overview of the social situation (reaching a general and initial view of the environment, issues, and needs) of the Shahid Maghul neighborhood and the Amirabad neighborhood is presented through direct observation. A focus group discussion and semi-structured interviews were conducted among various groups in the neighborhood, including age and gender groups, diverse ethnicities (Baloch, Afghan, Arab, Pakistani, etc.), and different religions. The economic and social problems and challenges of these neighborhoods were identified and analyzed.

1) Direct observation

2) Focus group discussion with members of the social council and some neighborhood trustees

3) Conducting in-depth interviews at the neighborhood level

The results of the interviews were divided into three categories as  Problems and needs arising from the opinions of the people and residents of the neighborhood, Problems and needs arising from the opinions of city managers and officials, and the problems and needs identified by the researcher during the field visit were classified and the final problem network of Shahid Maghul and Amirabad neighborhoods was identified in different dimensions with the help of the Steeple technique.

4. Conclusion

Development-stimulating and flagship projects, as influential initiatives in inner-city contexts, are a key component of the new policies in the regeneration approach. These projects can be effective in addressing many issues and problems in these contexts through targeted plans and micro-measures. These measures can be incorporated into the advancement of social, economic, and environmental policies and can also serve as a means to attract investments for the continuous regeneration of the urban texture, inspiring and guiding subsequent developments. Therefore, with the correct and timely implementation of projects that stimulate the development of the regeneration concept, meaning the process of developing all aspects of policies and improving the quality of life in these areas, it is realized. In the present study, in order to implement the idea of re-creation and realize its goals at the level of Shahid Maghul and Amirabad neighborhoods, in the first step, the most important challenges and issues of these neighborhoods were identified by holding a series of brainstorming sessions with the presence of members of the social council, local trustees and experts, urban managers and specialists, and by conducting field patrols and surveys. Then, the needs of the residents were surveyed to improve the quality of the environment and social welfare. Corresponding to each of the surveyed needs, stimulating, trust-building, and quick-return projects were identified. The most significant and pressing challenge and main need was the lack of suitable jobs for residents and the underutilization of the local labor force in industrial and workshop units in West Amirabad. Therefore, an attempt was made to summarize the results of a series of brainstorming sessions held with residents and experts and propose three practical and operational projects, including the establishment of a multipurpose cooperative company, the creation of a daily market in Ordibehesht and Amirabad gardens, and the holding of skill-based courses.

5. Aknowledgmant & Funding

·         The authors express their sincere gratitude to all interview participants for supporting this research.
This article did not receive any financial support from any organization.

6. Conflict of Interest

·         The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

 

Imanpour, M. R., Shams-al-Dini, A., & Sarvar, R. (2022). Identification and analysis of key drivers affecting informal settlement in Bojnourd city. Sustainable City Journal, (23), 165–182. ‌[in Persian]
Izadfar, N., & Izadfar, E. (2021). Developing a conceptual model for sustainable urban regeneration from a futures studies perspective. Urban Environment Policy Quarterly, 1(1), 30–44. ‌[in Persian]
Izadfar, A., Sasanpour, F., Toulaii, S., & Soleimani, M. (2020). Sustainable urban regeneration based on scenario planning: Case study of District 14, Isfahan Municipality. Urban–Regional Geography and Spatial Planning Quarterly, 10(34). ‌[in Persian]
Ariana, A., Mohammadi, M., & Kazemian, G. (2020). A conflict management model for stakeholders in urban regeneration in Iran: Case study of Hemmat-Abad Neighborhood, Isfahan. Urban Studies, (35), 117–132. ‌[in Persian]
Abtahi Foroushani, Z., Khoshnovapour, N., Forsatkar, E., & Abtahi Foroushani, T. (2015). Analysis of key stakeholders using the power–interest matrix: Case study of development plans in the South Pars region. Exploration and Production of Oil and Gas Monthly, (127). ‌[in Persian]
Bajalal, R., Feyzi, H., & Habibi, J. (2024). Urban regeneration through identifying networks of issues and defining local development catalyst projects. First Scientific–Applied Conference on Mashhad Urban Fringe. ‌[in Persian]
Bajalal, R., Daneshvar, M., & Habibi, J. (2024). Examination of the role and position of stakeholders and influencers in sustainable regeneration of deteriorated urban areas. Future Cities Outlook Quarterly, (issue unspecified). ‌[in Persian]
Bahraini, S. H., Izadi, M. S., & Mofidi, M. (2014). Approaches and policies in urban renewal: From reconstruction to sustainable urban regeneration. Urban Studies Research Journal, 17–30. ‌[in Persian]
Pourahmad, A., Ziyari, K., & Hosseini, A. (2015). Regeneration of urban distressed fabrics with emphasis on leisure spaces: Case study of Gheytarieh, Tehran. Spatial Planning and Development Quarterly, 19(3). ‌[in Persian]
Pourahmad, A., Habibi, K., & Keshavarz, M. (2010). Conceptual evolution of urban regeneration as an emerging approach in deteriorated urban areas. Iranian–Islamic City Studies Quarterly, (1). ‌[in Persian]
Taghafi, F., Abbasi, S., & Koshtgari, E. (2014). Designing a stakeholder identification and prioritization framework based on meta-synthesis. Future Management Scientific–Research Journal, 13(39). ‌[in Persian]
Rasouli, M., Ahadnejad, M., & Heydari, M. T. (2021). Importance–performance analysis of key success factors in regeneration of deteriorated urban areas with an emphasis on stakeholders. Urban and Regional Development Planning Quarterly, 6(16), 149–178. ‌[in Persian]
Khoshfar, Gh., Barghaei, R., & Karami, Sh. (2014). Social capital and urban sustainability: Case study of Gorgan. Urban Studies Scientific–Research Quarterly, 2(8), 31–46. ‌[in Persian]
Heydari, A., Davatalab, J., Ovisi Kheikha, Z., & Sahebzadeh, S. (2024). Analysis of the Paris Bobur neighborhood regeneration project using the creative problem-solving process. Urban Structure and Function Studies, (40). ‌[in Persian]
Hosseini, M. (2020). Thematic analysis of women’s social development with emphasis on sustainable empowerment. Iranian Journal of Social Development Studies, 13(1). ‌[in Persian]
Habibi, S. M., & Maghsoudi, M. (2010). Urban Restoration (New edition). Tehran: University of Tehran Press. ‌[in Persian]
Ramazani Farkhad, A., Akbari, H., Fouladian, M., & Mousaei, M. (2024). Emergence of an urban fringe in Golanshahr, Mashhad: A socio-economic analysis of the formation of Galeh-Khiaban neighborhood. Urban Geography and Spatial Development Quarterly, 1(11). ‌[in Persian]
Zangeneh, M., Abouyesani, K., & Barzuei, M. (2024). Assessing residents’ social capital for achieving urban regeneration: Case study of Joghatai’s deteriorated fabric. Urban Geography and Spatial Development Quarterly, 11(1). ‌[in Persian]
Zare, M., Bandarabad, A., & Shahabian, P. (2021). Urban regeneration through catalytic development projects: Case studies of Sang-e Siah (Shiraz), Ghal’e Mahmoud (Kerman), and Harunieh (Isfahan). Urban Research and Planning Journal, 12(47). ‌[in Persian]
Shahinifar, M., Pahekideh, E., Charehjou, …, & Khaledian (2020). Assessing the level of public participation in the renewal of deteriorated urban fabrics: Case study of old Kermanshah. Environmental Spatial Planning Quarterly, (48). ‌[in Persian]
Iran Urban Development and Revitalization Company. (2014). ‌[in Persian]
Sanaei-Moghadam, S., Anabestani, A. A., Rahmani, B., & Azizpour, F. (2024). Effects of livelihood diversification on rural household resilience to climate change: Case study of Pirashahr villages, Dehdasht. Spatial Economics and Rural Development. ‌[in Persian]
Sobhani Nobakht, S., Saeedi-Fard, F., Vahedi-Yeganeh, F., & Golchin, M. (2022). Urban regeneration, passive defense, and crisis management in deteriorated urban fabrics. Qazvin: Jihad Daneshgahi Publications. ‌[in Persian]
Sarvar, R., Na’mati, N., & Na’mati, M. (2020). Developing, screening, and prioritizing indicators for urban catalytic project planning: Case study of Tehran metropolis. Armanshahr Journal, 13(30). ‌[in Persian]
Asgari Tafreshi, M., Adibzadeh, B., Rafieian, M., & Hosseini, S. E. (2010). Environmental factors affecting renewal of deteriorated urban fabrics for improving local safety. City Identity Journal, 4(6). ‌[in Persian]
Gheysari, H., Modiri, A., & Kalantari Khalilabad, H. (2022). Stakeholder conflicts in the urban regeneration process: Case study of Si-e Tir Street, Tehran. Geographical Research Quarterly, 38(1), 73–83. ‌[in Persian]
Statistical Yearbook of Mashhad Urban Fringe (CD-ROM). (2020). ‌[in Persian]
Statistical Center of Iran. (1956). Statistical Yearbook of Tehran. ‌[in Persian]
Statistical Center of Iran. (1975). Statistical Yearbook of Tehran. ‌[in Persian]
Statistical Center of Iran. (2016). National Population and Housing Census. ‌[in Persian]
Malekzadeh, N., & Hashem Dadashpour, M. M. (2012). Assessing stakeholder and influencer participation in urban development strategies. Iranian–Islamic City Studies Quarterly, 2(8). ‌[in Persian]
Vahedi-Yeganeh, F., Meshkini, A., & Mohammadi, A. (2021). Analysis of the role of catalytic development projects in achieving urban regeneration policies: Case study of central Sanandaj. Urban Economics and Planning Quarterly, 3(3). ‌[in Persian]
Yeganeh, H., Ahadnejad-Ravashti, M., Piri, A., & Kalantari, M. (2020). A model for regeneration of deteriorated urban fabrics: Case study of Bisim District, Zanjan. (Doctoral dissertation, Zanjan University). ‌[in Persian]
Azizi, M. M., & Behara, B. (2017). The role of catalytic projects in regenerating central urban fabrics: Case study of historic Yazd. Fine Arts Journal, 22(4). ‌[in Persian]
Mohammadi, H., & Fakharzadeh, Z. (2022). Role of catalytic development projects in regeneration of deteriorated urban fabrics: Comparative analysis of Godal-e Mosalla and Sheikhdad neighborhoods (Case: University of Art and Architecture of Yazd). City Think-Tank Journal, 1(1). ‌[in Persian]
Attoe, W., & Logan, D. (1989) .American urban architecture: Catalysts in the design of city Berkley. University of California.
Alpopi C, Manole C. "Integrated urban regeneration, solution for cities revitalize", Procedia Economics and Finance, 2013. 6: 77-82.
Bohannon, L.C. (2004). The Urban Catalyst Concept. Wendy Jacobson. Blacksburg, Virginia. April 27
Davis, J. (2009). Urban Catalysts in Theory and Practice. Architectural Research Quarterly, 13 (3-4), 295 – 306.
Francin, K.I. (2015). Urban Catalyst. Supervised Research Project Submitted to Prof. Raphaël Fichler. School of
Urban Planning. McGill University.May.
Giannecchini P, Taylor I. The eastern industrial zone in Ethiopia: Catalyst for development?, Geoforum. 2018. 88, 28–35.
C., & Coccossis, H. (2004). Guidelines for urban regeneration in the_ Giorgio Tavano Blessi, Diane-Gabrielle Tremblay d, Marco Sandri, Thomas
McDonald, S., N. Malys & V. Maliene, "Urban Regeneration for Sustainable Communities: A Case Study", Technological and Economic Development of Economy, Vol. 15, No. 1, Pp. 49-59, 2009.
Li L, Hong G, Wang A, Liu B, Li Z. "Evaluating the performance of public involvement for sustainable urban regeneration", Procedia engineering. 2016. 145: 1493-1508.
Martinović A, Ifko S. Industrial heritage as a catalyst for urban regeneration in post conflict cities Case study: Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Cities the international journal of urban policy and planning. 2018
Sarvar, R., & Nematikutenaee, N. (2019). Urban Catalyst-A Strategy for Urban Development Planning and Management. Islamic Azad university, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, ISBN: 978-964-10-5694-2.
Pinson, G. (2010). Urban and Regional Planning. Bevir, Mark. Encyclopedia of Governance. 2, Sage Publications,
1005-1007, 2007.

فایل‌های تکمیلی/اضافی

  • تاریخ دریافت 27 اردیبهشت 1404
  • تاریخ بازنگری 12 خرداد 1404
  • تاریخ پذیرش 21 خرداد 1404
  • تاریخ اولین انتشار 21 خرداد 1404
  • تاریخ انتشار 01 مرداد 1404